A Climate for Investors. Climate Scenarios in the Network for Greening the Financial System

Alexandre Violle

doi:10.3384/VS.2001-5992.2025.12.2.258–282

Authors

Alexandre Violle Centre for the Sociology of Innovation, Mines Paris

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.3384/VS.2001-5992.2025.12.2.258–282

Keywords:

Financialization, Good economy, Climate scenarios, Risks, Boundary work, Central banks

Abstract

A growing body of scholarly contributions has shown how environmental issues are being “financialised”, as financial actors problematise the environment and the climate as a question of financial valuation. But what effects are their valuation processes having on financial and economic knowledge? By considering the case of the Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS), I show how central bank economists are trying to create a “climate for investors” out of climate change, defining climate scenarios that give banks incentives to finance low-carbon activities and thus encourage the transition to a “good global economy”. I argue that NGFS economists are doing boundary work that treads a path, carefully highlighting certain threats of climate change for an audience of investors, without losing their legitimacy or running the risk of appearing to be political actors. In doing so, these central bank economists are also transforming their understanding of what makes up national economies.

References

Aguiton, Sara. 2018. “Fortune de l’infortune. Financiarisation des catastrophes naturelles par l’assurance.” Zilsel 4(2), 21–57.

Akrich, Madeleine. (1992). “The De-Scription of Technical Objects”. In Shaping Technology/Building Society: Studies in Sociotechnical Change, edited by Wiebe Bijker and John Law, 205-224 Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Asdal, Kristin, Béatrice Cointe, Bård Hobaek, et al. 2021. “‘The Good Economy’: A Conceptual and Empirical Move for Investigating How Economies and Versions of the Good are Entangled.” BioSocieties 18(1): 1–24.

Allen, Thomas, Stéphane Dees, Jean Boissinot, et al. 2020. “Climate-Related Scenarios for Financial Stability Assessment: An Application to France”. Banque de France working papers, https://publications.banque-france.fr/sites/default/files/ medias/documents/wp774.pdf, accessed 21 June 2023.

Baudoin, Florian. 2022. “Les stress tests climatiques, entre politique de stabilité financière et tentative de transition écologique”, Master thesis. Paris Nanterre University.

Baudoin, Florian. 2023. “Les premiers pas de la supervision financière des risques climatiques par stress tests : une gestion prudentielle ou incitative?”, blog article, www.caissedesdepots.fr/blog/article/supervision-financiere-des-risques-climatiques-par-stress-tests, accessed 11 March 2023.

Birch, Kean and Fabian Muniesa (Eds). 2020. Assetization: Turning Things into Assets in Technoscientific Capitalism. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Bracking, Sarah. 2019. “Financialisation, Climate Finance, and the Calculative Challenges of Managing Environmental Change.” Antipode 51(3): 709–729.

Braun, Benjamin. 2016. “Speaking to the People? Money, Trust, and Central Bank Legitimacy in the Age of Quantitative Easing.” Review of International Political Economy 23(6): 1064–1092.

Carney, Mark. 2015. “Breaking the Tragedy of the Horizon – Climate Change and Financial Stability.” Speech given at Lloyd’s of London, 29: 220–230.

Chiapello, Eve. 2015. “Financialisation of Valuation.” Human Studies, 38(1): 13–35.

Christophers, Brett. 2017. “Climate Change and Financial Instability: Risk Disclosure and the Problematics of Neoliberal Governance.” Annals of the American Association of Geographers 107(5): 1108–1127.

Clerc, Laurent. 2020. “Évaluer les risques et les vulnérabilités et sensibiliser les acteurs financiers au risque de changement climatique : le rôle des stress tests.” Revue d’économie financière (2): 225–242.

Cointe, Béatrice, Christophe Cassen, and Alain Nadai. 2019. “Organising Policy-Relevant Knowledge for Climate Action: Integrated Assessment Modelling, the IPCC, and the Emergence of a Collective Expertise on Socioeconomic Emission Scenarios.” Science & Technology Studies 32(4): 36–57.

Collier, Stephen. 2008. “Enacting Catastrophe: Preparedness, Insurance, Budgetary Rationalization.” Economy and Society, 37(2): 224–250.

Coombs, Nathan, and Matthias, Thiemann. 2022. “Recentering Central Banks: Theorizing State-Economy Boundaries as Central Bank Effects.” Economy and Society, 51(4): 535–558.

Coombs, Nathan. 2022. “Narrating imagined crises: How central bank storytelling exerts infrastructural power.” Economy and Society, 51(4), 679-702.

De Goede, Marieke. 2004. “Repoliticizing Financial Risk.” Economy and Society, 33(2): 197–217.

Deyris, Jérôme. 2022. “Too Green to Be True? Forging a Climate Consensus at the European Central Bank.” New Political Economy 28(5), 713-730.

Engen, Stine (2025) “On Green Swans and Catastrophic Futures: Climate Change as Complexity Theory in Financial Regulation.” Valuation studies 12(1), 171-194.

Finance Watch. 2023. “Finance in a Hot House World.” Report, retrieved from: www.finance-watch.org/policy-portal/sustainable-finance/report-finance-in-a-hot-house-world/, assessed 10 October 2024.

Folkers, Andreas. 2024. “Risking Carbon Capital: Reporting Infrastructures and the Making of Financial Climate Risks.” Economy and Society 53(3), 504-526.

Fontan, Clément, and David Howarth. 2021. “The European Central Bank and the German Constitutional Court: Police Patrols and Fire Alarms.” Politics and Governance, 9(2): 241–251.

Grandjean, Alain, and Julien Lefournier. 2021. L’illusion de la finance verte. paris: Éditions de l’Atelier.

Gieryn, Thomas F. 1983. “Boundary-Work and the Demarcation of Science from Non-Science: Strains and Interests in Professional Ideologies of Scientists.” American Sociological Review 48(6):781–795.

Glaser, Barney, and Anselm Strauss. 2017. Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. New York: Routledge.

Gray, Ian. 2021. “Hazardous Simulations: Pricing Climate Risk in US Coastal Insurance Markets.” Economy and Society 50(2): 196–223.

Hilgartner, Stephen. 2000. Science on Stage: Expert Advice as Public Drama. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

Jasanoff, Sheila S. 1987. “Contested Boundaries in Policy-Relevant Science.” Social Studies of Science 17(2): 195–230.

Jasanoff, Sheila S. 2004. “The Idiom of Co-Production.” In States of knowledge. Edited by Sheila Jasanoff,1–12. New York: Routledge.

Langley, Paul. 2013. “Anticipating Uncertainty, Reviving Risk? On the Stress Testing of Finance in Crisis.” Economy and Society 42(1): 51–73.

Langley, Paul, and John, Morris. 2020. “Central banks: Climate governors of last resort?” Environment and Planning A: Economy and Space, 52(8): 1471–1479.

Latour, Bruno. 1993. We Have Never Been Modern. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Laurent, Brice. (2016). “Boundary-Making in the International Organization: Public Engagement Expertise at the OECD.” In Knowing Governance: The Epistemic Construction of Political Order, edited by Voss, Jan-Peter and Richard Freeman, 217–235. London: Palgrave Macmillan UK.

Laurent, Brice. 2017. Democratic Experiments: Problematizing Nanotechnology and Democracy in Europe and the United States. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Leyshon, Andrew, and Nigel Thrift. 2007. “The Capitalization of Almost Everything: The Future of Finance and Capitalism.” Theory, Culture & Society 24(7–8): 97–115.

Massoc, Elsa. 2022. “Climate Change Versus Price Stability: How ‘Green’ Central Bankers and Members of the European Parliament Became Pragmatic (Yet Precarious) Bedfellows.” SSRN Journal LawFin working paper No. 33.

McPhilemy, Samuel, and Manuela Moschella. 2019. “Central Banks under Stress: Reputation, Accountability and Regulatory Coherence.” Public Administration 97(3): 489–498.

Mennicken, Andrea, and Peter Miller. 2012. “Accounting, Territorialization and Power.” Foucault Studies 13(May): 4–24.

Miller, Clark. (2001). “Hybrid Management: Boundary Organizations, Science Policy, and Environmental Governance in the Climate Regime.” Science, Technology, & Human Values 26(4): 478–500.

Mitchell, Timothy. 1998. “Fixing the Economy.” Cultural Studies 12(1): 82–101.

Monnet, Eric, and Jens Vant’t Klooster. 2023. “Using Green Credit Policy to bring Down Inflation: What Central Bankers Can Learn from History Policy.” The Inspire Sustainable Central Banking Toolbox, Briefing Paper 13.

Montagne, Sabine, and Horacio Ortiz. 2013. “Sociologie de l’agence financière: enjeux et perspectives: Introduction.” Sociétés contemporaines (4): 7–33.

Morris, John H., and Hannah Collins. 2023. (Mis) managing Macroprudential Expectations: How Central Banks Govern Financial and Climate Tail Risks. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing.

Mudge, Stephanie, and Antoine Vauchez. 2016. “Fielding Supranationalism: The European Central Bank as a Field Effect.” The Sociological Review 64(2): 146–169.

Muniesa, Fabian, and Dominique Linhardt. 2011. “Trials of Explicitness in the Implementation of Public Management Reform.” Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 22(6): 550–566.

Muniesa Fabian, Liliana Doganova, Horacio Ortiz, Alvaro Pina-Stranger, Florence Paterson, Alaric Bourgoin, Véra Ehrenstein, Pierre-André Juven, David Pontille, Basak Saraç-Lesavre, Guillaume Yon. 2017. Capitalization: A Cultural Guide. Paris: Presses des Mines.

Ortiz, Horacio. 2013. “Financial Value: Economic, Moral, Political, Global.” Journal of Ethnographic Theory – HAU, 3(1): 64–69.

Ortiz, Horacio. 2014. “The Limits of Financial Imagination: Free Investors, Efficient Markets and Crisis.” American Anthropologist 116(1): 38–50.

Ortiz, Horacio. 2021. The Everyday Practice of Valuation and Investment: Political Imaginaries of Shareholder Value. New York: Columbia University Press.

Preda, Alex. 2005. “The Investor as a Cultural Figure of Global Capitalism.” In The Sociology of Financial Markets, edited by Karin Knorr Cetina, and Alex Preda, 141–162. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Quorning, Stine. 2023. “The ‘Climate Shift’ in Central Banks: How Field Arbitrageurs Paved the Way for Climate Stress Testing.” Review of International Political Economy 31(1). 74-96.

Sullivan, S. (2013). Banking Nature? “The Spectacular Financialisation of Environmental Conservation." Antipode 45(1), 198-217.

Thiemann, Matthias, Tim Büttner, and Olivier Kessler. 2023. “Beyond Market Neutrality? Central Banks and the Problem of Climate Change.” Finance and Society 9(1): 14–34.

Van’t Klooster, Jens. 2022. “Technocratic Keynesianism: A Paradigm Shift without Legislative Change.” New Political Economy 27(5): 771–787.

Van’t Klooster, Jens, and Clément Fontan. 2020. “The Myth of Market Neutrality: A Comparative Study of the European Central Bank’s and the Swiss National Bank’s Corporate Security Purchases.” New Political Economy, 25(6): 865–879.

Violle, Alexandre. 2017. “Banking Supervision and the Politics of Verification: The 2014 Stress Test in the European Banking Union.” Economy and Society, 46(3–4), 432–451.